Frequently Asked Questions

New to Magic, or just to Gatehouse Games? Here are answers to the questions we hear most.

Buying cards

Are your prices in Canadian dollars? Where do they come from?

Yes, every price on the site is in Canadian dollars (CAD). Our prices start from North American market prices published by Scryfall, which come from TCGplayer and are in US dollars. We convert them at the Bank of Canada's daily exchange rate, then adjust for the card's condition. Prices are refreshed every day, so they follow the market.

Ready to look around? Browse the catalog.

What do NM, LP, MP and HP mean?

They describe how much wear a card has. Every card we sell is graded by hand before it goes on sale.

  • NM — Near Mint: looks unplayed or close to it. At most a tiny bit of edge or corner wear you'd need to look closely to notice.
  • LP — Lightly Played: light wear, such as small white marks on the edges or corners and a few light scratches. Looks great in a sleeve.
  • MP — Moderately Played: clearly used. More edge and corner wear, scuffing, or a small crease. Still fine to play in a sleeve.
  • HP — Heavily Played: lots of wear, such as heavy whitening, creases or scratches, but the card is whole and readable.
  • Damaged: major problems such as tears, water damage or writing.

Lower grades cost less and play exactly the same, so they're a good way to save money if you only want the card for your deck.

What do nonfoil, foil and etched mean?

They're the card's finish. Nonfoil is the regular printed card. Foil has a shiny, rainbow-like surface. Etched foil has a textured, metallic look that shows up mostly in the card's frame. Some cards also come in other special finishes. The same card can exist in several finishes, usually at different prices.

Why are there so many versions of the same card?

Popular cards get reprinted in many sets, often with different artwork or frames. On a card's page you can choose the set, condition and finish you want. We start you on the cheapest version we have in stock, and you can switch to the others from there.

Are your cards authentic?

Yes. Every card we buy is checked for both condition and authenticity before it goes on sale, with extra care for valuable cards.

The card I want is out of stock. Can I be told when it's back?

Yes. Click “Notify me” on the card and we'll email you when it's back in stock (at most one email a day). You'll need an account for this, and you can see everything you're waiting on in your wishlist.

Can I buy a whole decklist at once?

Yes. Use Import Decklist (also on the search page), paste your list, and add everything we have in stock to your cart in one click.

Selling to us

What is a buylist, and how does selling my cards work?

A buylist is the list of cards a store will buy from you, and what it will pay. Here is how selling to us works:

  1. Add your cards on the Sell page: search for them, paste a list, or browse a set.
  2. Get a quote and choose cash or store credit.
  3. Submit it. We review your list and let you know what we're taking.
  4. Ship your cards to us, packed in the order shown on your submission.
  5. We check each card's condition and authenticity when it arrives.
  6. You get paid.

You can look up prices and build a quote without an account. You'll need to sign in to submit it. You can follow every step from your account.

Should I choose cash or store credit?

It's up to you. Store credit pays a higher percentage than cash and can be spent on anything in the store, including shipping. Cash is sent by Interac e-Transfer or PayPal to the email address you give us.

What if my card isn't in the condition I expected?

Quotes assume Near Mint. If a card grades lower when it arrives, we pay the price for its actual condition, or we may turn it down. For any card we don't take, you choose whether we send it back (at your cost), hold it to ship with your next order, or donate it. The full details are in our Terms of Service.

Do you buy large collections?

Yes. For a large collection, get in touch. We can also arrange in-person pickup in the Kitchener–Waterloo area.

Deck Builder tools

Why do I need an account to use the Deck Builder and Deck Upgrader?

These tools use AI, which costs us money every time they run. To keep them free for everyone, each account gets 3 free runs a week (we call them tokens), and you can buy more if you need them. You can look at both tools without an account. Sign in when you're ready to run one.

What's the difference between the Deck Builder and the Deck Upgrader?

The Deck Builder builds a whole deck from our stock based on your format, colours, theme and budget. The Deck Upgrader takes a deck you already have and suggests cards to improve it. Either way, we only suggest cards that are in stock and legal in your format, so you can add them straight to your cart.

Orders, shipping & your account

How does checkout work? Is it secure?

Payment is handled by Stripe, a payment company used by millions of businesses. Your card details go straight to Stripe; we never see or store your card number. You'll need an account to check out so you can track your order. Sales tax (GST/HST) is worked out for your province at checkout.

How do I sign in? Is there a password?

There's no password. Enter your email on the sign-in page and we'll email you a link that signs you in. You can also sign in with Google. Open the link on the same device and browser you requested it from, or it won't work.

Where do you ship, and how much does shipping cost?

We ship from Ontario to anywhere in Canada. In your cart, enter your address to see the real Canada Post options and prices before you pay. Small orders can also go by cheaper lettermail, which has no tracking.

I forgot something after placing my order. Do I have to pay shipping again?

Usually not. Until we've bought the shipping label for your first order, you can place a second one and choose “Add to order #…” as the shipping option. It ships in the same box, free.

My card arrived damaged, or it's the wrong card. What do I do?

Sorry about that! Open the order from your orders and report the problem with a photo or two. We'll sort it out with a refund, replacement or store credit.

Can I cancel my order?

Yes, as long as it hasn't shipped yet. Contact us and we'll cancel it and give you a full refund.

What is store credit, and how do I use it?

Store credit is money in your account that you can spend here. You get it from selling cards to us, from resolved claims, and from rewards. It's applied at checkout and can cover your whole order, shipping included. Your balance is on your account page.

Still have a question?

We're happy to help. Send us a message and we'll get back to you within 2 business days.

Contact Us